Graham Wilson

graham.wilson@conted.ox.ac.uk


Hats, Hawaiian Shirts and the Limits of Good Manners

·

,

On changing social conventions, courtesy and the obligation to consider others.

I like to think of myself as a fairly liberal person. I have little patience with those who complain about the young, lament the decline of standards, or insist that things were better in their day. Social conventions change, and most of the time I welcome that change.

But I have a problem with hats.

More precisely, I find myself irritated by people wearing hats indoors. Not baseball caps worn by young people, which might allow me to dismiss my response as generational prejudice. No, the people who catch my attention tend to be older adults, wearing ordinary hats while sitting in restaurants or attending meetings.

I find this faintly offensive. Recent events, however, have made me wonder whether my irritation has less to do with hats than with something more fundamental.

A question of occasion

Yesterday I attended a conference. Almost everyone wore formal business attire. I wore a suit, tie and a shirt without a button-down collar, something I hadn’t done all year. I wouldn’t normally choose such clothes, but I recognised the nature of the occasion.

One speaker took a different approach. He wore jeans, a Hawaiian-pattern shirt and an unstructured jacket. Against a room full of formal clothing, he stood out.

His words and style of delivery conveyed considerable arrogance. When his highly technical presentation failed to work as intended, he became visibly irritated. His clothing didn’t create my impression of arrogance. His conduct did that. But his appearance seemed consistent with the impression he had already made.

Of course, there may have been innocent reasons for his choice of clothes. Yet when someone behaves with apparent conceit, departures from shared conventions can suggest something more than personal taste. The message, whether intended or not, can seem to be that the rules applying to everyone else don’t apply to them.

Hats at dinner

Later, in a small restaurant, I encountered a party of about fourteen British and American diners. Two wore hats throughout the meal, but it was the conduct of the wider group that troubled me.

The American contingent spoke at an extraordinary volume. Their voices dominated the room, accompanied by occasional swearing. I have no objection to people enjoying themselves, but there is a difference between having a good time and imposing that good time on everyone else.

The hats were a minor matter by comparison. Yet they contributed to my impression of people giving insufficient thought to those around them.

There is a question I would like to ask those who wear hats indoors. Would you wear yours in a church or a law court?

I suspect many wouldn’t. They would recognise that the setting called for respect and that removing a hat was one way of expressing it. There are, of course, religious and medical exceptions. But if people understand the convention in those settings, why should a restaurant be different?

I don’t expect formal clothing at dinner. But restaurants are shared social spaces. We make small concessions to other people through the way we dress, speak and behave. These conventions can make social life more pleasant, even when they serve no obvious practical purpose.

The psychology of courtesy

Psychologists distinguish between descriptive norms, which concern what people tend to do, and injunctive norms, which concern what people believe they ought to do (Cialdini et al., 1990). The two don’t always agree.

People may increasingly wear hats indoors or dress casually at formal events without everyone considering such behaviour appropriate.

Yet there is an important distinction between a social convention and a moral principle. Removing a hat is a convention. Avoiding needless disturbance to others is a matter of consideration.

Erving Goffman (1967) examined the small rituals through which people acknowledge one another in everyday encounters. These rituals needn’t express deference to authority. They can communicate something simpler: I recognise that you are here, that your presence matters, and that my preferences aren’t the only ones that count.

That, I think, comes closer to the source of my irritation.

When someone dresses for a formal occasion, they may be expressing respect for the organisers and those attending. When diners moderate their voices, they acknowledge that others have an equal claim to enjoy the space.

The acts themselves may seem trivial. The consideration behind them is not.

The obligation to consider others

What connects these experiences is not the wearing of hats or the choice of clothes, but the question of how much thought we give to the people around us.

A conference, like a restaurant, is a shared social occasion. We attend with certain expectations about how people will behave. Those expectations needn’t be rigid, but they help us show respect for one another.

When we choose how to dress or behave, we make a judgement about the occasion and our place within it. Sometimes that judgement reflects a wish to fit in; sometimes it expresses a wish to stand apart. Neither choice is wrong in itself.

But I think there is a difference between making a personal choice and assuming that our choice need take no account of anyone else.

Perhaps this is why I find some breaches of convention irritating. They can suggest that the person concerned considers their own preferences more important than the expectations of those around them. That may not be their intention, but it can be the impression they create.

Good manners, at their best, aren’t about obedience to rules or deference to status. They are about recognising that other people matter. They ask us to make small adjustments to our own behaviour so that others can enjoy the same space.

That seems to me a reasonable expectation, whatever our age or views about social conventions.

Am I just getting old?

I remain uneasy about my response to hats because I recognise how easily criticism of manners can become criticism of people who differ from ourselves.

Every generation watches familiar conventions disappear. The temptation is to interpret this as a decline in standards rather than a change in customs.

Perhaps my reaction owes something to the rules I learned in childhood. Removing a hat indoors was simply what a well-mannered person did. I still react when someone ignores that rule, even though I struggle to explain the harm.

But good manners aren’t merely outdated rules about hats, clothing and table settings. At their best, they express consideration for others. They ask us to notice where we are, who else is present and how our behaviour affects them.

Perhaps the real test of courtesy isn’t whether someone knows which hat to remove or which shirt to wear. It is whether they recognise that other people have feelings, expectations and needs that deserve as much consideration as their own.

I shall probably continue to notice hats worn indoors. I should, however, distinguish between a harmless breach of an old convention and conduct that shows genuine disregard for others.

All the same, I still wish they’d take the damned things off.


References

Cialdini, R. B., Reno, R. R., & Kallgren, C. A. (1990). A focus theory of normative conduct: Recycling the concept of norms to reduce littering in public places. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 58(6), 1015–1026. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.58.6.1015

Goffman, E. (1967). Interaction ritual: Essays on face-to-face behavior. Anchor Books.

Comments

Leave a Reply